NewKalent + Marvin: AI-powered sourcing in your ATS
Book a demoDemo

Guidesentretien9 min read

Interview scorecard:
free template, criteria and rating scale.

An interview scorecard sets, before a job interview, the criteria, the questions and the rating scale. A template ready to copy, a five-step method, sample questions by criterion and what French law forbids you to ask.

Christophe Hébert, CEO and founderUpdated
Contents

Contents

0% read

An interview scorecard is the document that sets, before a job interview, the criteria to assess for the role, the questions to ask for each and the rating scale. Every interviewer uses it the same way, for every candidate: you then compare answers to the same questions, rated on the same scale, and the decision can be justified.

This guide gives a template ready to copy, the method to adapt it to a role in five steps, sample questions by criterion and what French employment law forbids you to ask.

Guide updated on 11 November 2026.

The interview scorecard template

The template below can be copied into a spreadsheet or a shared document. Each row is a criterion, with the main question, what a good answer looks like and the score. Replace the criteria with those of your role; the structure stays the same from one hire to the next.

Header: role, candidate, date, interviewer, type of interview (phone, video, on site).

Criterion Main question Good answer (score 3 or 4) Score (1 to 4) Fact noted
Technical skill 1 “Tell me about the last project where you used [skill].” A specific project, a clear personal role, a measurable result
Technical skill 2 “How would you handle [real situation from the role]?” A structured approach, constraints identified
Organisation and priorities “Describe a week when everything came at once. What did you leave aside?” Explicit criteria for choosing, consequences owned
Working with others “Tell me about a disagreement with a colleague or a client. How did you resolve it?” Facts, listening, a concrete outcome
Motivation for the role “What makes you apply here, and not elsewhere?” Knows the role and the company, a coherent plan
Practical conditions Availability, notice period, expected salary, mobility if the role requires it Compatible with the offer Yes / No

Summary: strengths, points to watch, overall score, recommendation (proceed, do not proceed, to review) and next step.

Building your scorecard in five steps

A useful scorecard is built from the role, not from a generic template. Start from the job description, keep the criteria that make someone succeed in the role, write one question per criterion, describe each score on the scale, then check that every interviewer reads it the same way.

  1. Start from the job description. List the tasks and the results expected in the first year. If there is no job description, now is the time to write one: see our guide is a job description mandatory?, with a template.
  2. Keep five to seven criteria. For each task, ask what sets apart someone who succeeds. Separate what is essential from what can be learnt on the job.
  3. Write one question per criterion. Prefer questions about a past fact (“tell me about the last time…”) to hypothetical ones: they require a real example. Plan two follow-ups: “what exactly was your role?”, “what was the result?”.
  4. Describe each score. For each criterion, write what earns 1, 2, 3 and 4. This is the step most often skipped, and the one that makes scores comparable.
  5. Calibrate between interviewers. Have two people score the same interview, or the same report. A gap of more than one point on a criterion signals a description to sharpen.

The rating scale: 1 to 4, described criterion by criterion

An even scale, from 1 to 4, forces a decision: there is no middle score in which to park a candidate you are unsure about. Each score is described for each criterion, in terms of observable facts, so that two interviewers give the same score to the same interview.

Score Meaning Example for “managing a project”
1 Insufficient No example, or an example where they had no role of their own
2 Partial Contributed to a project without being responsible for it
3 Satisfactory Led a comparable project alone, with a measurable result
4 Beyond expectations Led several larger projects, and can say what they would change

Score straight after the interview, criterion by criterion, before discussing it with a colleague: another interviewer's first impression shifts the scores. Write next to each score the fact that justifies it. A score with no fact behind it cannot be defended in a debrief, nor to a candidate who asks why they were not selected.

Sample questions by criterion

The best interview questions ask about a past fact that is specific and verifiable. They ask the candidate to describe a real situation, what they did themselves and the result. Here are questions by criterion, to adapt to the role; one or two per criterion are enough in a one-hour interview.

Technical skills

  • “Show me how you solved [common problem in the role] the last time.”
  • “Which tool do you use for [task], and what did you set up in it yourself?”

Organisation

  • “How did you organise your last month-end close, your last launch, your last busy period?”
  • “Tell me about a deadline you missed. What did you do next?”

Relationships and communication

  • “Tell me about a difficult client or colleague. What did you actually say?”
  • “How did you break bad news to your manager?”

Motivation

  • “What did you like in your last job, and what made you leave?”
  • “What would you like to be doing in a year that you are not doing today?”

What an interview scorecard must not contain

In France, the Labour Code governs what an interviewer may ask. Information requested from a candidate can only serve to assess their ability to do the job or their professional aptitudes, and must have a direct and necessary link with the role (article L1221-6). Any question on a discrimination ground is excluded.

The discrimination grounds listed in article L1132-1 include origin, sex, age, family situation, pregnancy, sexual orientation, gender identity, health and disability, political opinions, union activities, religious beliefs, physical appearance, surname and place of residence.

Two more rules apply to the scorecard itself. The candidate is told in advance which assessment methods are used, which must be relevant to their purpose, and the results remain confidential (article L1221-8). Scores and comments are personal data: they are kept for a limited time and the candidate can access them.

In Marvin

Marvin's interview reports (Suite plan, paid with the licence credits) offer an “evaluation grid” template. From the interview transcript and the CV, the AI fills in the grid: general information, technical and behavioural skills with a level and the example from the conversation that supports it, points to watch, then the score and recommendation.

The score out of 5 and the recommendation are only filled in if the interviewer stated them during the interview; otherwise, the grid leaves them “to be completed by the recruiter”. You can also create your own report templates, with your own criteria. The report is attached to the candidate's profile, in Marvin's candidate tracking by job.

Frequently asked questions

What is an interview scorecard?

It is a document prepared before a job interview that lists the criteria to assess for the role, the questions to ask for each and the rating scale. Every interviewer uses it the same way for every candidate, which lets you compare them on the same basis and justify the decision.

Which criteria should an interview scorecard include?

Five to seven criteria taken from the job description: two or three essential technical skills, two or three behavioural skills, motivation for the role and practical conditions such as availability and salary. Beyond seven, scores get diluted and the interview leaves no time to check everything.

Which rating scale should you use?

A scale from 1 to 4, with no middle score, forces a choice between insufficient and satisfactory. Each score must be described for each criterion, for example “3: has already led a comparable project alone, with a measurable result”. Without these descriptions, two interviewers score the same candidate differently.

Which questions are forbidden in a job interview in France?

Any question without a direct and necessary link to the job or to professional aptitudes (article L1221-6 of the French Labour Code), and any question on a discrimination ground listed in article L1132-1: family situation, pregnancy, origin, religion, political opinions, union activity, health, place of residence, among others.

What is the difference between an interview scorecard and an interview report?

The scorecard is prepared before the interview: it sets what you will assess and how. The report is written afterwards: it records what the candidate said, the scores given and the recommendation. A good practice is to write the report in the scorecard’s structure, criterion by criterion.

Sources

Christophe HébertCEO and founder

CEO and founder of Marvin. A former recruiter turned tech entrepreneur, he is building the operating system for modern recruiting.

Never lose an application again. See how, in 30 minutes.